AI Help for Insurance Agents › Guides › Getting started
How to start using AI at your insurance agency: a step-by-step plan
Start here
- One bottleneck, one tool, one month. Fix the thing that hurts most before you touch anything else.
- Consent before you text or call. Set a written consent step before an AI tool messages or phones a client.
- Make it write back to your AMS. If quotes, notes, and messages don't land on the client record, you've built a second system to reconcile.
- Decide with real numbers. Hours saved, calls answered, quotes turned faster, renewals kept. Keep the tool only if the math holds.
- Ask for a written price. Most agency tools are quote-based, so get a number for your staff count before you commit.
Step 1: pick the one bottleneck that costs you most
Before you spend anything, name a single problem. For most small P&C (property and casualty) agencies it's one of three: quoting takes too long and you lose the shopper, calls after hours go to voicemail and never come back, or renewals slip because nobody had time to reach out.
Pick the one that's costing you real money right now. Ignore the other two for the first month. Trying to fix everything at once is how agencies end up with three half-used subscriptions and no habit.
Step 2: try one tool for a month
Choose one tool aimed at that bottleneck and use it on real work for a full month. Match the tool to the problem:
- Quoting speed -- a comparative rater like Tarmika pulls quotes from several carriers at once so you're not re-keying the same submission into each portal. Quote-based; ask for a price.
- After-hours calls -- an AI phone answering tool like Sonant can pick up the phone when the office is closed, take details, and hand off to you. Quote-based.
- Renewals and follow-up -- a client texting and reviews tool like Podium (from about $399 a month) keeps renewal reminders and review requests moving without you chasing each one by hand.
Run one tool, not three. Use it on every relevant account for the month and judge it on your own book.
Step 3: set a consent process before any texting or calling
Before an AI tool texts a client, places an automated call, or answers your phone, put a written consent step in place. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) generally expects prior express consent for many texts and automated calls, and callers using an AI voice need to be disclosed to the person on the line.
Keep it simple: a consent line on your intake and quote forms, a record of who said yes and when, and a clear way for a client to opt out. The exact rules vary and change, so confirm the specifics with a licensed professional or your state department of insurance (DOI = the state office that regulates insurance). The compliance guide walks through this in plain terms.
Step 4: check that it writes back to your AMS
Your agency management system (AMS) is the software that holds your client and policy records -- for many independent agencies that's HawkSoft, EZLynx, AMS360, or Applied Epic. Any new tool has to feed it, not compete with it.
Before you rely on a tool, test one real account end to end. Did the quote, the call notes, or the text thread land on the client record in your AMS? If it didn't, you've created a second place to look and something to reconcile later. Confirm the writeback works before you roll it out to the whole book.
Step 5: decide with real numbers
After a month, look at what actually changed. Count the hours saved, the after-hours calls answered, the quotes you turned around faster, the renewals that didn't slip. If the tool earned its keep, keep it. If it didn't, drop it without guilt.
Price it honestly too. Most agency tools are quote-based, so ask each vendor for a written price for your staff count before you commit. Two tools we cover publish a starting figure: GloveBox from about $150 a month and Podium from about $399 a month. For the raters and agency management systems, you'll need to ask.
Step 6: or hire a local pro to set it up
If the migration, the integration, or the setup keeps sliding down the list, hand it off. The find-a-pro search below shows local AI consultants who do this work for insurance agencies, by zip code. Free to use, and we don't take a cut of what you pay them.
What will it cost to start?
It depends on which bottleneck you fix and how many people are on your staff. Here's the honest picture on pricing for the tools on this site:
| Tool | What it's for | Starting price |
|---|---|---|
| GloveBox | Client service and self-service app | From about $150/mo |
| Podium | Client texting, reviews, follow-up | From about $399/mo |
| Tarmika | Comparative rating / quoting | Quote-based -- ask the vendor |
| Sonant | AI phone answering | Quote-based -- ask the vendor |
| HawkSoft, EZLynx, AMS360, Applied Epic | Agency management systems | Quote-based -- ask the vendor |
Most agency software is priced by quote, so there's no single starting number we can give you honestly. Ask each vendor for a written price for your staff count, and confirm current pricing before you sign -- it changes.
Common questions
Do I need a technical background to start?
No. Most of these tools are built for agencies, and setup usually means creating an account, connecting your agency management system, and adding a consent step. The parts worth care are the AMS writeback and the consent process. If either stalls, hand it to a local consultant.
Which bottleneck should I fix first?
Pick the one costing you the most right now. If slow quotes lose you shoppers, start with quoting and rating. If you miss calls after hours, start with AI phone answering. If renewals slip, start there. One tool, one problem, one month.
What will it cost to start?
It varies, and most agency tools are quote-based, so ask each vendor for a price for your staff count. Two publish a starting figure: GloveBox from about $150 a month and Podium from about $399 a month. Raters and agency management systems like Tarmika, HawkSoft, EZLynx, AMS360, and Applied Epic are quote-based.
What if the first tool doesn't fit after a month?
Drop it and try another. Your consent process and the AMS writeback habit carry over to whatever you pick next, so that work is never wasted. Ask about contract length before you sign, so a one-month trial doesn't lock you into a year.
Sources: starting prices published by GloveBox (gloveboxapp.com) and Podium (podium.com), vendor-published and subject to change -- confirm before you buy. Other tools named here are quote-based; ask each vendor. Consent context: the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, general information at fcc.gov; confirm rules with your state department of insurance and a licensed professional. This page is general information, not legal, compliance, or insurance advice -- those obligations stay with your agency. Last reviewed: 2026-07-29.
Want the setup handled for you?
Find a local AI consultant who sets up quoting tools, AI phone answering, client texting, and agency management systems for insurance agencies -- by zip code.
Find a local AI pro →